Contact us on (02) 8445 2300
For all customer service and order enquiries

Woodslane Online Catalogues

9780813218830 Academic Inspection Copy

Thomas Aquinas and the Philosophy of Punishment

Description
Author
Biography
Reviews
Google
Preview
Thomas Aquinas and the Philosophy of Punishment explores how Aquinas's understandings of natural law and the common good apply to the contemporary philosophical discussion of punitive justice. It is the first book-length study to consider this question in decades, and the only book that confronts modern views of the topic. Peter Karl Koritansky presents Thomas Aquinas's theory of punishment as an alternative to the leading schools of thought that have dominated the philosophical landscape in recent times, namely, utilitarianism and retributivism. After carefully examining each one and tracing its roots back to Immanuel Kant and Jeremy Bentham, Koritansky concludes that neither approach to punitive justice is able to provide a philosophically compelling justification for the institution of punishment. He explains how St. Thomas approaches the same philosophical questions from a markedly different set of assumptions rooted in his theory of natural law and his understanding of the common good. Not without its own difficulties, Aquinas's approach offers a rationale and justification of punishment that is, Koritansky argues, much more humane, realistic, and compelling than either contemporary school is able to provide. Koritansky distinguishes his reading of the Angelic Doctor from that of other interpreters who tend to conflate Aquinas's teaching with various aspects of recent thought. A final chapter considers the death penalty in John Paul II's Gospel of Life and debates whether current Catholic teaching about the death penalty conflicts with Aquinas's arguments in favour of the death penalty.
Peter Karl Koritansky is assistant professor of philosophy and religion at the University of Prince Edward Island.
"Koritansky uses Lawrence Dewan to good effect in emphasizing the importance of the political common good Koritansky ably distinguishes Aquinas's retributivism from that of Kant In all, Koritansky provides a good introduction to the thought of Aquinas on punishment."--Steven J. Jensen, The Thomist "Koritansky provides a good introduction to the thought of Aquinas on punishment. He places Aquinas's thought within the context of modern views and shows how it can remedy many of the defects found in contemporary thought."--Steven J. Jensen, The Thomist
Google Preview content